Hacker News users are expressing nostalgia for the detailed profiles and high-investment experience of early OkCupid, contrasting it with the low-effort swiping mechanics of modern mobile apps. Many commenters criticize Match Group's business model and suggest a market opportunity exists for a new competitor that revives evidence-based matching and rich user profiles. However, others argue that increased cultural cynicism makes it impossible to fully recapture the optimistic dating dynamics of the 2010s.